Veissier, I.; Caré, S. & Pomiès, D. (2013) “Suckling, weaning, and the development of oral behaviours in dairy calves”, Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 147, pp. Orcas consume fish and other marine mammals, we must consume living vegetable matter at least, and when we die, we become food for a host of microorganisms, nourishing them in turn. Krutzinna, C.; Boehncke, E. & Herrmann, H.-J. 1036-1057 [accessed on 24 June 2014]. (1998) Human-livestock interactions: The stockperson and the productivity and welfare of intensively farmed animals, Wallingford: CAB International. Want an ad-free experience?Subscribe to Independent Premium. The use of animals as commodities extends further than what we choose to put in our mouths. Dr Gordon Shepherd, from the Yale School of Medicine, said sniffing and analysing a wine before drinking it requires “exquisite control of one of the biggest muscles in the body”, : In heartening news for anyone feeling guilty about quitting their New Year diet, it seems lots of us have given in to our sweet tooths once again. Titled the DAIRY PRIDE Act, the name is a tenuous acronym for ‘defending against imitations and replacements of yogurt, milk, and cheese to promote regular intake of dairy every day’. Finally, they are given food formulas that are poor in nutrients such as minerals, in particular iron, so their flesh remains pale and tender. The raisin and biscuit-filled chocolate bar is being launched after a successful trial last summer saw 3 million chocolate treats – at the cost of £1.49 for each 95g bar- purchased by nostalgic customers. Opposing meat eating on ontological grounds – meaning, simply because animals are sentient beings, we shouldn’t eat them – separates humans from nature and prevents truly ethical relationships between humans, animals and the natural world. The traditional western diet is “high in saturated fats, salt, and sugar, and low in fibre” (Knight and Leitsberger) because people are The health of calves reared in this way is typically better than that of those kept indoors, not only because they can eat better but also because they are able to exercise. 1674-1682. 153-164. 11-18; Daros, R. R.; Costa, J. H. C.; von Keyserlingk, M. A. G.; Hötzel, M. J. & Weary, D. M. (2014) “Separation from the dam causes negative judgement bias in dairy calves”, PLOS ONE, 9 (5) [accessed on 2 June 2014]. When they are outdoors, however, they often lack any shelter, and may have to endure harsh weather conditions. Millions of birds are traded internationally each year. "Once a child starts overeating behaviour at a young age it’s very hard to turn things around for them in terms of food and their eating habits moving forward, leading to obesity from at very young age," she added, According to Tesco, pineapple has overtaken avocado as the UK’s fastest-selling fruit, with sales increasing by 15 per cent in 2017. 271-276. 3287-3296. In the simplest terms, animal exploitation in the suffering of animals for the benefit people. Ontological veganism asserts that beings that count as ethical subjects should not be eaten, in the same way that there’s a widespread taboo about eating humans. Published in journal Nature Metabolism, the study found that while BCAAs help to build muscle, they can also negatively impact an individual's temperament, cause weight gain and lead to a shortened lifespan, Most people love chocolate but it turns out no one does more than the Brits – with the average Brit found to have consumed 8.4 kg of chocolate in 2017, according to new data. They are with you, not for you.” This quote is from the late utopian author Ursula Le Guin, in her novel Always Coming Home. Cows and their sons, calves and steers, are exploited for several purposes. (2000) “Behavioural response to humans and the productivity of commercial dairy cows”, Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 66, pp. The successful candidate will help them to test, perfect and launch new products all over the world. Examples of the connections between human and animal exploitation are starkly exhibited in meat packing plants and leather tanneries. Wild animal suffering: An introduction; The situation of animals in the wild; Why wild animal suffering matters; Helping animals in the wild Leather is often obtained from animals which are also exploited for food, thus contributing to the exploitation of these animals. B. Directorate-General for Health and Food Safety (2017) Welfare of cattle on dairy farms, Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union [accessed on 28 November 2018]. The bigger picture of wildlife exploitation The global wildlife trade – which makes using wild animals as entertainment, food, medicine, and pets possible – is at the heart of animal cruelty and is the reason why we are facing this pandemic. When a cow’s production decreases she is killed. 7 Thomas, V. M. (1986) Beef cattle production: An integrated approach, Philadelphia: Lea & Febiger. It would be feasible to exploit the cow and yet not separate her from her calves and kill them when they are just babies. In either case, the animals feel much pain not only when they lose their tail, but also afterwards. (eds.) Friend, T. H.; Dellmeier, G. R. & Gbur, E. E. (1985) “Comparison of four methods of calf confinement. In contrast, others think animals should be utilised to assist humans in various kinds of ways, such as the source of food or for medical testing. Munksgaard, L.; Ingvartsen, K. L.; Pedersen, L. J. Males are castrated because it increases their growth rate and because it reduces aggression between them in feeding lots and during transport. When buying the new spread you can also buy an optional toasted bagel. The major causes of bovine perinatal mortality are dystocia (35%) and anoxia (30%).4. Animals used for food; Animals used for clothing; Animals used for entertainment; Animal experimentation; Animals kept as companions or for leisure; Animals as workers and tools; Veganism; WILD ANIMAL SUFFERING. 469-478. However, while we’re busy filling our shopping trolleys with gluten-free goodness, we’re also jamming it with junk food and alcohol, new research suggests. This is often done through artificial insemination, with semen obtained from bulls who have been selected to have daughters who secrete large quantities of milk. One pack has 154 calories and will sell for about 90p. 8 Albright, J. L. (1972) “To dock or not to dock tails”, Hoard’s Dairyman, 117, pp. 339-348. Cambridge PhD graduate-turned farmer, Adrian Izzard has used traditional growing techniques at Wild Country Organics to produce the colourful spuds, packed with healthy cell-protecting anthocyanin, which had previously disappeared from UK plates when post-war farmers were pushed towards higher-yielding varieties, Veganism doesn’t mean framing the use and consumption of animals itself as inherently exploitative (Getty/iStock), Support free-thinking journalism and attend Independent events, Vegan sausage roll gave Greggs ‘exceptional’ sales boost in early 2019, Pancake Day 2019: Five best vegan and gluten-free recipes, Miley Cyrus shares photos of vegan wedding to Liam Hemsworth, The cons outweigh the pros when it comes to veganism, researchers say, Before you go vegan, think about why you're doing it, Booking.com discount code: 10% with Level 1 Genius membership, Use this Debenhams discount and save up to 70% on men's lines - Spring offer, 20% off fitness with this exclusive Ideal World promo code, Save £4 on your purchase with an AliExpress promo code for new customers, Argos kids: 25% off PAW Patrol toys, baby & nursery items. This can last for around 10 months, after which point they are made pregnant again. According to the weekly report from the Government’s Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, a pair of Little Gem lettuces had an average market price of £0.86 in the week that ended on Friday, up from an average of £0.56 in the previous week – that’s an almost 54 per cent increase. 133-134. The restaurant was praised for a fun sense of fine-dining, “blurring the line between the kitchen and the dining room”, Researchers at Feinberg School of Medicine, Northwestern University in Chicago recently presented their results of a study looking into the effects of sleep deprivation upon high-calorific food consumption. Stull, C. L. & McDonough, S. P. (1994) “Multidisciplinary approach to evaluating welfare of veal calves in commercial facilities”, Journal of Animal Science, 72, pp. Chocolate consumption around the world is on the rise, according to Mintel Global New Products Database (GNPD), which found that in the past year alone, Easter chocolate production has risen by 23 per cent, Dr Becky Spelman, chief psychologist at Harley Street’s Private Therapy Clinic, is calling for Easter eggs to be banned for consumption for children under the age of four, claiming that giving them the opportunity to binge on chocolate so young will give them an unhealthy relationship with food later on. What’s more, the skin is actually edible, unlike a regular avocado. To deny this is to deny that humans are embedded within the ecosystems they originate from and are sustained by. I. Physiology”, Journal of Animal Science, 60, pp. © 2021 Animal Ethics But consider forms of mutual use seen in symbiotic relationships, such as those between pollinating insects and plants. 10 Graf, B. (2001) “Assessing the welfare of dairy cattle”, Journal of Applied Animal Welfare Science, 4, pp. In addition, it is done to reduce the harm that steers can cause to each other if they are bred together in feedlots, since they are crowded and stressed there and fights can occur. The new bar, named Goodness Knows, will replace the gooey caramel goodness of the mars bar with oats. It has become a debatable topic about the exploitation of animals by mankind. When they start to eat solid food, they are given food products with high concentrations of grains designed to make them grow as much as possible. It is a form of animal cruelty and can be done in many different ways such as animal testing to farming to cub petting and trophy hunting. 153-171. Huge tracts of land and millions of gallons of water are needed to grow, feed, and raise these animals. 4 Mee, J. F. (2013) “Why do so many calves die on modern dairy farms and what can we do about calf welfare in the future?”, Animals, 3, pp. Ontological veganism would frame using or consuming animals itself as inherently exploitative. With this technique, embryos produced by certain cows selected for the purpose of producing embryos (sometimes called “supercows”) are transferred to recipient cows. Some of us – especially those living in wealthy countries – can indeed choose to opt for vegan products, but this argument reproduces another false dichotomy: nature vs culture. Whay, H. R. & Shearer, J. K. (2017) “The impact of lameness on welfare of the dairy cow”, Veterinary Clinics of North America: Food Animal Practice, 33, pp. When we steal from animals, for instance, we’re exploiting their vulnerabilities. Huxley, J. N.; Main, D. C. J.; Whay, H. R. Burke, J. 909-915. To encourage more people to cook and eat together, IKEA has launched The Dining Club in Shoreditch – a fully immersive ‘Do-It-Yourself’ restaurant . Bourguet, C.; Deiss, V.; Cohen Tannugi, C. & Terlouw, E. M. C. (2011) “Behavioural and physiological reactions of cattle in a commercial abattoir: Relationships with organisational aspects of the abattoir and animal characteristics”, Meat Science, 88, pp. Start your Independent Premium subscription today. However, the suffering of billions of animals each year in factory farming, referred to in a 2015 Guardian article as one of the “worst crimes in history”, is the most powerful motivation for many, including myself. However, the consumption of milk and veal is linked, and by demanding one of these products we are promoting the production of the other. Beyond their role in the food supply, freshwater and marine fish are also trapped for the aquarium trade and fished for sport. Some of them are kept for their entire lives in indoor feedlots. But I'd remained a vegetarian, and so hoped to discover that the exploitation of animals for food and science had been reduced since the 1980s. She may be used for three, four or sometimes five lactations. Castration can be done by simply cutting the animals’ testicles, by cutting the spermatic cord or by placing a very tight rubber cord over the testicles which stops the blood flow to them. Exploitation of Animals Essay. 5 Friend, T. H. & Dellmeier, G. R. (1988) “Common practices and problems related to artificially rearing calves: An ethological analysis”, Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 20, pp. (2003) “The effect of abrupt weaning of suckler calves on the plasma concentrations of cortisol, catecholamines, leukocytes, acute-phase proteins and in vitro interferon-gamma production”, Journal of Animal Science, 81, pp. The Cold Brew Vanilla sweet cream and the Cappuccino Freddo, will both be available in stores throughout the UK from the start of May, The Cadbury Dairy Milk Tiffin, first produced in 1937, is making a permanent comeback to the UK. We are all food, and crucially, so much more. Others spend the first six months of their lives outdoors. EXPLOITATION. (2007) “A critical review of fear tests used on cattle, pigs, sheep, poultry and horses”, Physiology & Behavior, 92, pp. Supported by their very own sous chef and maître de, the host and their guests will orchestrate an intimate dining experience where cooking together is celebrated and eating together is inspirational, Gatwick Airport has teamed up with London dim sum restaurant Ping Pong to create a limited edition menu with a distinctly British twist; including a Full English Bao and Beef Wellington Puff, to celebrate the launch of the airport’s new route to Hong Kong, Unique pizza art has been created by Zizzi in celebration of the Queen’s 90th birthday. Milk replacers are used because the milk produced by cows is sold for human consumption. By framing the consumption of other living beings as an inherent moral wrong, ontological veganism also risks demonising predation. When they are older other methods may be used, such as simply sawing the horns off, or using clippers to cut them off. The late environmental philosopher Val Plumwood coined “ontological veganism” to describe this absolute opposition. This is not only bad for the animals because it makes them weak, but also because it causes them very severe digestive disorders. Domestic Breeding. Metz, J. H. M. & Groenestein, C. M. Pet stores are easy enough to find in nearly any city, and you may think to run to … It is important to bear this is in mind since many people in good faith reject eating meat because they don’t want to eat animals yet consume dairy products in the … Starbucks have introduced their new avocado spread earlier this year and it has the internet in debate. Environmental Exploitation - “ The way that we breed animals for food is a threat to the planet . Wiepkema, P. R.; Van Hellemond, K. K.; Roessingh, P. & Romberg, H. (1987) “Behaviour and abomasal damage in individual veal calves”, Applied Animal Behavior Science, 18, pp. Few vegans will … In addition many dairy cows have been injected with bovine somatotrophin, a peptide hormone which has been genetically engineered to increase their productivity. This has been made possible by using genetic selection and artificial breeding, as well as by changes to the nutritional content of their food. It argues that the dairy industry is struggling as a result of all the dairy-free alternatives on the market and the public are being duped too, UK confectionary giant Cadbury has launched two new chocolate bars, hoping to lure those with a sweet tooth and perhaps help combat some of the challenges it faces from rising commodity prices and a post-Brexit slump in the value of the pound.The company’s new products will be peanut butter and mint flavoured. Diet choices are dangerous when they demonise nature, Gluten-free breads, dairy-free milks and other plant-based products have been some of the most favoured foods in British supermarkets this year. Also, if they don’t have horns the bruises they might suffer during their transport can be reduced. "This is a nightmare situation for parents of this generation as they have no idea how to teach their children to delay their response to cravings,” she said, explaining that too many young kids binge on these chocolates because their parents don’t know how to stop them. Problems can occur, the most common being that the supercow embryo is too large for the recipient cow. While being moderately healthy Mars says that is has ‘good intentions’. It pollutes our environment while consuming huge amounts of water, grain, petroleum, … You can take them, you can eat them, like you they are food. Donations are tax-deductible to the full extent allowed by law. Turner, S. P. & Lawrence, A. It is said to be more like a Florentine biscuit with a thin dark chocolate bottom. Such views are often bolstered by powerful moral arguments framing animals as subjects of a life, able to experience pain, and as leaders of complex emotional lives. (1992) Calf rearing, Dublin: Teagasc. The use of leather, which is part of the economic value of these animals, also contributes to this exploitation. As any act does, animal exploitation has consequences. The answer is yes, and yes especially because farm animals are generally now under the control of business corporations. & Appleby, M. C. (2003) “Farm animal welfare: The interaction between ethical questions and animal welfare science”, Animal Welfare, 12, pp. Those calves that are not used to produce veal are raised to produce “beef”. Fallon, R. J. In fact, because they are never able to exercise,6 their muscles are so atrophied that they may even have problems walking when they are transported to the slaughterhouse. 'Scottie's Pizza Parlor' in Portland Oregon has created the world’s cheesiest pizza using a total of 101 different cheese varieties. This will mark the first time the German franchise of the fast food chain has offered a vegan burger to its customers. Mark Hawthorne shines a light on the truth about how animals are inhumanely used and how they suffer at our hands. Eating animals is natural, says Heather Alberro, but the mass exploitation of animals in factory farming is not, Find your bookmarks in your Independent Premium section, under my profile. If humans are indeed animals who differ from other species only by degrees rather than kind, then like them, we are food. Once you have read this book, you will know the truth about how these animals live behind closed doors exploited … It is served in a classic sesame seed bun, and contains salad, tomato, pickles and red onion. Close to 30 percent of globally threatened birds are affected by overexploitation, particularly … Her idea is akin to Plumwood’s theory of ecological animalism, which seeks to replace human supremacy over nature with mutual and respectful use between humans and other species. The mass production and systematic killing of animals for food is where we see the greatest amount of suffering for animals, and notably this includes human animals as well. Schreiner, D. A. 351-358. Yet they are still taken from their mothers, which causes them much distress, and are usually killed while they are between only three and 18 weeks old. Animals kept as companions or for leisure, Wild animal suffering video course – Summary, Reproductive strategies and wild animal suffering, Separation from the dam causes negative judgement bias in dairy calves. Mellor, D. & Stafford, K. (1999) “Assessing and minimising the distress caused by painful husbandry procedures in ruminants”, In Practice, 21, pp. Scientists showed that those who drank between two and four cups of coffee a day had 18% lower risk of death compared to non-coffee drinkers. While the rise of human civilization did in fact rely on animals as food resources, the continuation of human civilization does not rely on animals as food resources. & Mullord, M. M. (1977) “Investigations of maternal bonding in dairy cattle”, Applied Animal Ethology, 3, pp. Wool, silk, leather, feather, suede, fur, ivory, down are just some examples of the many ways animals are unnecessarily exploited for human benefit. Coca-Cola want people make this move while not sacrificing sugary taste of Coca-Cola. Go vegan whenever and wherever possible, but be mindful of the underlying rationales involved, lest we reproduce the same harmful dualisms we want to dismantle. (1996) “Organic milk production in Germany”, Biological Agriculture & Horticulture: An International Journal for Sustainable Production Systems, 13, pp. Animal Exploitation. What I … They are killed when they have grown enough that it is no longer profitable to feed and keep them, usually between the ages of six to nine months. Sandøe, P.; Christiansen, S. B. The iconic British chocolate bar is about to get its partner in crime. This is not done, however, because more milk can be obtained by separating them and because it permits the maintenance of the veal industry. This is often done at the same time that the animals are castrated. & Senn, M. (1999) “Behavioural and physiological responses of calves to dehorning by heat cauterization with or without local anaesthesia”, Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 62, pp. If her life were respected she could live up to 25 years or more. To reject the killing of animals one must also reject dairy production. As soon as the cows give birth, their calves are taken away from them. In this way, the lives of cows consist of a continuous cycle of being impregnated, giving birth to a calf who is taken from her, being milked and then, only a few months later, being impregnated again. 223-234. 340-374. 2131-2144. The popular supermarket says the surge in popularity comes as shoppers buying the versatile fruit are beginning to use it as a main ingredient in everything from curries and barbecues, to juices and cocktails, Rather than the result of genetic modification, the avocados are formed by an unpollinated avocado blossom. St.-Pierre, N. R.; Cobanov, B. Making the switch to veganism is a major lifestyle choice, one that many claim can improve energy levels, lower the risk of cardiovascular disease and clear up any skin issues. West, J. W. (2003) “Effects of heat-stress on production in dairy cattle”, Journal of Dairy Science, 86, pp. In cultures all around the world, animal products are used for food, clothes, and also for medicine. Members of the public can book to host a brunch, lunch or dinner party for up to 20 friends and family. 89-100. He suggested “[t]he principle of the emancipation of 2847-2855. “Come among the deer on the hill, the fish in the river, the quail in the meadows. Animal exploitation can take many forms. (1993) “Investigating welfare of dairy calves involved in genetic modification: problems and perspectives”, Livestock Production Science, 36, pp. Eicher, S. D. (2001) “Transportation of cattle in the dairy industry: Current research and future directions”, Journal of Dairy Science, 84, suppl., pp. Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Bretschneider, G. (2005) “Effects of age and method of castration on performance and stress response of beef male cattle: A review”, Livestock Production Science, 97, pp. As we have seen above, calves are separated from their mothers shortly after coming into existence. The pizza features the queen in an iconic pose illustrated with fresh and tasty Italian ingredients on a backdrop of the Union Jack, Blue potatoes, once a staple part of British potato crops, are back on the menu thanks to a Cambridge scientist turned-organic farmer and Farmdrop, an online marketplace that lets people buy direct from local farms. Eleven Madison Park won the accolade for the first time after debuting on the list at number 50 in 2010. Their lives end as soon as they are fat enough for the purpose for which they were bred. (2007) “Relationship between maternal defensive aggression, fear of handling and other maternal care traits in beef cows”, Livestock Science, 106, pp. In other cases they have slightly more room and are kept in individual pens, yet they are nevertheless alone and deprived of any social contact. In some cases, calves are reared with nurse cows (who are not their mothers). (2005) “The effects of weaning beef calves in two stages on their behavior and growth rate”, Journal of Animal Science, 83, pp. Some argue that it not a spread but guacamole while others question if there is any avocado in there at all. The tails of cows are cut. (1991) New trends in veal calf production: Proceedings of the International Symposium on Veal Calf Production, Wageningen: Centre for Agricultural Publishing and Documentation. The fruit develops without a seed which in turns stops the growth, creating a small, seedless fruit. Cows are mammals. In some cases, even their heads are held in place so they can’t move them at all. In another cases, calves die during or immediately following birth. Rushen, J.; de Pasille, A. M.; Munksgaard, L. (1999) “Fear of people by cows and effects on milk yield behavior and heart rate at milking”, Journal of Dairy Science, 82, pp. 1095-1101. They need not have any lethal condition, but simply, for any reason, may not be profitable to raise for “veal” or “beef” production. Pain and pessimism: Dairy calves exhibit negative judgement bias following hot-iron disbudding. In other cases, the calves are not taken away immediately, but are left with their mothers for one or two days so they can suckle the colostrum from their mothers, which boosts their resistance to some diseases. Veissier, I.; Gesmier, V.; Le Neindre, P.; Gautier, J. Y. Stull, C. & Reynolds, J. Cook, N. B.; Mentink, R. L.; Bennett, T. B. This article originally appeared on The Conversation, Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies. Calves considered to be “non-viable” are killed the same day they are born. For years, we’ve been told MSG (the sodium salt of glutamic acid) - often associated with cheap Chinese takeaways - is awful for our health and to be avoided at all costs. (1998) “Undesirable side effects of selection for high production efficiency in farm animals: A review”, Livestock Production Science, 56, pp. We can judge the heart of a man by his treatment of animals.” Immanuel Kant (22 April, 1724 – 12 February, 1804), German philosopher of the Enlightenment Era. That is, if they survive. 237-239. New data from nationwide food-delivery service Deliveroo reveals there was a surge in Brits ordering desserts in February compared to the first month of 2017, A new bill has been created that seeks to ban dairy alternatives from using the term ‘milk’. 2 Rushen, J. It can be done by simply cutting their tails with a sharp instrument, or it can be done by putting a rubber ring very tightly around the tail until a point at which the tail dies. Hudson, S. J. The flesh is much like that of a normal avocado - smooth and creamy, pale in colour and rich in flavour, The average bacterial reading of an office teabag was 3,785, in comparison to only 220 for a toilet seat. A lot of places are not up front about how their animals are treated, so it is worth looking into before purchasing make up or planning your next trip. 47-62. Animal agriculture involves the production of livestock and animal by-products for human consumption. the exploitation of animals for food, in particular, industrial animal agriculture, aquaculture, and fishing. The environmental impact of this practice is detrimental to the land, air, and water and involves the unsustainable use of fossil fuels. Also, as would be expected, they are less stressed than those kept in individual pens or stalls. Ecological animalism offers a powerful basis for truly ethical and egalitarian ways of relating to other species. 420-426. Animal Ethics is a 501(c)(3) public charity. No wonder Aldous Huxley observed in his poignant ecotopian work, Island, that: “For animals … Satan, quite obviously, is Homo sapiens.”. In order to maximize profit, their well-being is a concern Heather Alberro is an associate lecturer and PhD candidate in political ecology at Nottingham Trent University. The raising and killing of animals for the production of certain types of foods is the most common one, though animals are also killed to produce clothing, for entertainment, or to be used as labor or tools, including their use as laboratory tools. Orcas consume fish and other marine mammals, we must consume living vegetable matter at least, and when we die, we become food for a host of … 182-188. In the case of animals used for food production, we coin (either we “call this” or “we coin the term”) this “animal exploitation”. BCAA supplements are often consumed in the form of powder, which is then added to water to make a shake. It is important to bear this is in mind since many people in good faith reject eating meat because they don’t want to eat animals yet consume dairy products in the belief this is not harmful to them. Her body is then used to produce “ground beef”, which is commonly consumed in hamburgers. 437-440. This is done in order to reduce the risks to workers in the transport, handling and killing of animals. Humans do not require these ‘products’ and in fact, have a variety of … Life is entanglement, with no clear boundaries between “humans” and other species, or between “nature” and “society”.
Field Hockey Summer Camps 2021 Near Me,
Hilton Hotel Rules And Regulations,
Arcane Adaptation Vs Conspiracy,
Future Memes Twitter,
What Animal Is Tabaqui,
Disadvantages Of Science Parks,
Lord Of The Flies Vocabulary Chapter 3-4,
Should Animals Perform In Circuses Balanced Argument,